Critical Thinking
Today's world
demands critical thinking and on-the-fly problem solving, where, increasingly
even blue-collar jobs require acquisition and analysis of complex information,
rather than rote task performance of a known set of steps in a fixed order,
an Industrial Age construct, which in the Information Age is less often
effective. Skills needed to be successful in the Digital Age include
working independently and creatively without too much "hand holding".
Industries that focus on information technology and a more freewheeling
labor market are demanding dynamic self-starters -- not the conservative
graduates of the establishment . (Ellsworth,2000, p. 2; Cohen, 1999;
Desruisseaux, 1999b; Coleman; 2000a, p. 10).
Between January
1995 and 1998, the number of jobs increased by over 6 million and only
1 million left the ranks of the unemployed. He adds nearly two out
of three of the 17 million full-time jobs added since 1998 were in the
professional, managerial, and technical occupations; in 1996, these occupations
accounted for only about on in four jobs. Many of the new jobs require
creativity and critical thinking, for example, jobs for actors, college
professors, social scientists, reporters, and lawyers have doubled and
tripled at the rate of nonprofessional jobs and college professor jobs
have risen from 125,000 in 1950 to around 850,000 in 1995 (Lerman, 1998,
p. 2).
Cooperative
learning activities help develop abilities in problem solving, critical
thinking and teamwork. Computer technology structures and facilitates
cooperative learning experiences. The interactive components of the
Web, in particular, facilitates communication, enhances cross-cultural
exchanges, and encourages the use of technology. (Quick, and Lieb,
2001, p. 41; The National Alliance of Business (NAB), 1999, p. 2).
Critical thinking
is concerned with reason, intellectual honesty, and open-mindedness, as
opposed to emotionalism, intellectual laziness, and close-mindedness. It
follows that critical thinking involves: following evidence where it leads;
considering all possibilities; relying on reason rather than emotion; being
precise; considering a variety of possible viewpoints and explanations;
weighing the effects of motives and biases; being concerned more with finding
the truth than with being right; not rejecting unpopular views without
consideration; being aware of one's own prejudices and biases, and not
allowing them to sway one's judgment. (Fowler, B., 1996, Longview
Community College)
If we take Logic
to be the activity of drawing inferences (conclusions) from a body of information,
then no doubt humans have been using logic for as long as they have been
thinking, or at least consciously thinking. They probably drew logically
correct conclusions from their data about as often as folks do nowadays,
i.e. maybe 62.3% of the time. Logic, as the analysis of concepts
involved in making inferences, and the identification of standards and
patterns of correct inference, can be traced only back to the days of Aristotle,
Theophrastus (Aristotle's successor as head of the Peripatetic school),
Eudemus (Theophrastus's successor), and in early Hindu writings,
beginning around 350 B.C. Aristotle's influence is sustained
until, in the 16th century, Pierre de la Ramee (Petrus Ramus) developed
a widely influential anti-Aristoleian position, a deductive logic.
Modern logic was developed in the 19th and 20th centuries. It was
at this time logic received renewed interest (and an emphasis on symbolic
representation), from mathematicians in search of a fundamental connection
between logical and mathematical reasoning. Development of, and reaction
to, this line of inquiry led to two divergent lines of emphasis in the
study of logic: Symbolic (formal) logic vs critical thinking (informal)
logic. In symbolic logic, emphasis is placed on the precise symbolic
representation of logical concepts, the study of the abstract relationships
between these concepts, and the systematization of these relationships.
In informal logic or critical thinking, the focus is on the application
of logical concepts to the analysis of everyday reasoning and problem solving.
Elements of symbolic logic will frequently be involved, but only to the
extent that it contributes to this practical objective. (Lauren Miller
and Michael Connelly, 1996, Longview Community College)
Critical thinking
is defined by several authors in:
Critical Thinking
Across the Curriculum Project: Critical Thinking Definitions
Contributed
by Barbara Fowler, Longview Community College.
http://www.kcmetro.cc.mo.us/longview/ctac/definitions.htm
A critical thinker:
-
asks pertinent
questions
-
assesses statements
and arguments
-
is able to admit
a lack of understanding or information
-
has a sense of
curiosity
-
is interested in
finding new solutions
-
is able to clearly
define a set of criteria for analyzing ideas
-
is willing to examine
beliefs, assumptions, and opinions and weigh them against facts
-
listens carefully
to others and is able to give feedback
-
sees that critical
thinking is a lifelong process of self assessment
-
suspends judgment
until all facts have been gathered and considered
-
looks for evidence
to support assumption and beliefs
-
are able to adjust
opinions when new facts are found
-
looks for proof
-
examines problems
closely
-
are able to reject
information that is incorrect or irrelevant.
(Ferrett, S. Peak
Performance, 1997).
Critical thinkers
are able to distinguish between the validity of a philosophical truth,
a statement made to convince another of a truism and a political truth
which is a statement made to solicit agreement, regardless of the truth
of the statement where power and control are primary concerns. The
statement would be valid if (and only if) all the premises are true; then the conclusion must be true too.
Information Competency
Information Competency or Information Literacy is the ability to locate,
evaluate, and synthesize information in response to a specific information need.
These critical thinking skills include the following abilities:
- To recognize and articulate
problems as an information need
- To determine what type of
information is required to solve a problem
- To know how to locate
relevant information
- To develop research
strategies to discover desired information
- To evaluate the reliability
of information based on origin and currency
- To incorporate and synthesize
information
- To communicate information
using various technology modes
Information competency embodies
fundamental skills necessary for academic achievement and lifelong learning. The
ability to identify and resolve one’s own information needs is a prerequisite to
success in education, work, and personal life.
CRITICAL
READING
Links to
More Information
Information Competency
Tutorials
Santa Ana College
http://ext.sac.edu/academic_progs/library/informationcompetency/index.html
Critical Thinking Core Concepts
http://www.kcmetro.cc.mo.us/longview/ctac/corenotes.htm
Thinking Critically
about Discipline Based World Wide Web Resources.
UCLA College
Library Instruction
http://www2.widener.edu/Wolfgram-Memorial-Library/pyramid.htm
|